Coauthored byLixin LiuandPatrick Kim
刘立新和帕特里克·金合着
This article was written before the launch of oursecond-generation hardware wallets, which we are striving to make as open source as possible for the mass market. Our first-generation Cobo Vault Ultimate had a more specialized design targeted at institutional investors, who have an interest in using closed source hardware under service agreements with liability insurance. For our first generation, we believed the risks of opening the door to hackers outweighed the potential benefits of attracting developers to contribute to making our product more robust.
本文是在第二代硬件钱包发布之前撰写的他们对根据责任保险与服务协议使用封闭源硬件感兴趣。 对于我们的第一代人来说我们相信向黑客敞开大门的风险远胜于吸引开发人员为使我们的产品更强大做出贡献的潜在好处。
As passionate advocates of open source software, we have deep respect for pioneering developers who made their work available to the world, and it goes without saying that we in the cryptocurrency field owe much to the originators of blockchain technology. It is because Satoshi Nakamoto and other great trailblazers made their work open source that we are all able to share in the benefits brought by amazing innovations such as Linux, Bitcoin, and the booming cryptocurrency market.
作为开源软件的热情拥护者不用说我们所有人都能分享Linux比特币和蓬勃发展的加密货币市场等惊人创新所带来的收益。
However, when it comes to the question of whether making source code available is beneficial for the security of hardware wallets, we enter into a wholly new discussion. This article explains our reasons why we believe the nature of open source does not represent an upgrade for hardware wallets, but rather a significant security compromise.
但是我们进入了一个全新的讨论。 本文解释了我们为什么认为开放源代码的本质并不代表硬件钱包的升级而是重大的安全性折衷的原因。
In traditional fields of computing, supporters of open source have consistently emphasized one point — open source is safer because it enables the public to inspect source code and contribute to security by helping fix potential loopholes. Linus’s law is clearly illustrated by the statistic that a zero-day attack on Safari, a closed source, takes an average 9 days to fix, while a zero-day attack on Firefox, an open source, on average only takes a single day to fix.
在传统的计算领域中因为它使公众能够检查源代码并通过帮助修复潜在漏洞来为安全做出贡献。 统计数据清楚地说明了Linus的定律(“给了足够多的眼球对Safari的零日攻击(封闭源)平均需要9天的修复时间一个开放源代码平均只需要一天的时间就可以解决。
However, Linus’s law must be understood in context, namely that of traditional computing fields. When discussing the advantages of open source software in terms of hardware wallets, we must be mindful of the fact that the traditional computing development community is immense compared to that of hardware wallets.
但是即传统计算领域的定律。 在讨论开源软件在硬件钱包方面的优势时即与硬件钱包相比传统的计算开发社区规模巨大。
GitHub, the world’s largest host of source code, indicates that there are only around 180 contributors to the open source code of the oldest hardware wallet brand, Trezor. This statistic stands in sharp contrast with the communities of other hardware products such as the Raspberry Pi, whose contributors to its open source firmware number around 9,500.
GitHub是全球最大的源代码托管者Raspberry Pi为其开源固件数量大约为9,500做出了贡献。
No project, no matter how big, is entirely immune to the potential dangers of exposing its code. Take for example Linux Mint, which washacked in 2016. Although that backdoor issue was fixed within a day, the rapid response time was in no small part due to the size of the Linux open source community.
无论项目多大它在2016年被黑客入侵。 尽管该后门问题在一天内得到解决快速响应时间在很大程度上不容小small。
In the context of our relatively small development community, we need to be especially wary of the fact that sharing source code is a double-edged sword. For hardware wallets, the unfortunate truth is that releasing source code makes it easier for hackers to detect loopholes and carry out attacks. Open source code can even open the door for cybercriminals to produce counterfeit hardware wallets capable of deceiving consumers — a security threat Trezor has alreadybeen the victim of.
在我们的开发社区相对较小的情况下不幸的事实是以生产能够欺骗消费者的假冒硬件钱包-Trezor已经成为安全威胁。
An aspect of security hardware wallet owners need to be keenly aware of iszero-day attacks. In zero-day attacks, the period of time between when a previously unknown vulnerability is exposed or announced and when it is fixed presents a perfect window of opportunity for a hacker to carry out an attack. Because vulnerabilities in hardware wallets are often resolved through firmware upgrades, it usually takes a while after official security patches have been released for users to actually install them and fix the issue. With some users who, after having set up their hardware wallet, don’t open it for months or even years, exposure to zero-day attacks is dramatically increased. Perhaps counterintuitively for those experienced with open source software development, a black box, or device with a closed source code, is more secure than a white box with an open source code.
安全硬件钱包所有者需要敏锐地意识到零日攻击。 在零日攻击中因此通常需要一段时间才能发布正式的安全补丁遭受零日攻击的风险急剧增加。 对于具有开放源代码软件开发经验的人来说黑匣子或具有封闭源代码的设备比具有开放源代码的白箱更安全。
While it is tempting to fall back on our knowledge and appreciation of Bitcoin as a prime example of the security offered by open source code, to assume that all blockchain projects should follow suit and become open source is a logical leap. The security Bitcoin enjoys from its open source development community is a direct result of the scale of its community involvement. Whether it is source code or mining functions, the Bitcoin community has gotten involved in maintaining and protecting the project, with larger numbers of involvement correlating to more secure functionality. However, because there are comparatively so few developers currently involved in hardware wallet security, we can make no assumptions about the benefits of sharing source code carrying over to this space.
虽然倾向于依靠我们对比特币的了解和欣赏作为开放源代码提供的安全性的主要示例比特币社区都已参与维护和保护项目由于目前涉及硬件钱包安全性的开发人员相对较少因此我们无法假设共享源代码到此空间的好处。
Apart from vastly increasing the number of reviewers inspecting code, another benefit of open source development in traditional computing fields is enabling anyone to download, install, burn, debug, or even remove certain aspects of the source code themselves.
除了大量增加检查代码的审阅者之外任何人都可以自己下载刻录调试甚至删除源代码的某些方面。
The security that comes with this level of autonomy is reliant on a foundation of specific technologies. However, even with a solid technological base, there is always the potential for security measures to be outdone. Those in computing fields will be familiar with how theKen Thompson Hack (KTH)created a backdoor in the C compiler than can conceivably monitor or place controls on any software program in the world. You would have to write your own compiler using binary code or use tools compiled before KTH was installed in order to overcome this security compromise. KTH demonstrates that any system compiled from a source code is always going to be vulnerable to attack.
这种自治级别带来的安全性取决于特定技术的基础。 但是安全措施也总是有可能被淘汰。 计算领域的技术人员会熟悉Ken Thompson Hack(KTH)如何在C编译器中创建后门或者使用在安装KTH之前已编译的工具从源代码编译的任何系统始终容易受到攻击。
What OGs like Ken Thompson teach us is that unless you are able to write your own compiler , you’re going to have to put your trust in a third-party. In-depth issues such as having to write your own compiler aside, the majority of hardware wallet users won’t even get their feet wet burning or debugging source code. For this cohort of users, knowing their hardware wallet is open source is more of a psychological comfort than a condition that actually amounts to a measurable improvement in their wallet’s security.
In traditional fields of computing, it helps to think of the security brought by open source software as enabling a kind of “audit” on the source code. While the same is not yet true of cold storage cryptocurrency security, what can instead be substituted as a reliable source of “audit” for hardware wallets?
在传统的计算领域但是可以替代什么作为硬件钱包“可靠”的可靠来源
Fortunately, signed transaction outputs are not nearly as complicated as the outputs of other types of software. If making source code available is not the most secure option of providing ways to audit hardware wallets, we can instead consider scrutinizing their transaction signing outputs.
幸运的是我们可以考虑仔细检查其交易签名输出。
People purchase hardware wallets because they know the most secure way to store their private keys is to take them offline into cold storage. All hardware wallet services need a means of communicating between offline storage and online terminals. While the cold end is responsible for storing private keys and signing transactions, a hot end is needed to obtain data from the blockchain, construct transactions for the cold storage end to sign, and broadcast signed transactions to the blockchain.
人们购买硬件钱包是因为他们知道存储私钥最安全的方法是将其离线放入冷存储器。 所有硬件钱包服务都需要一种在离线存储和在线终端之间进行通信的方式。 冷端(离线存储)负责存储私钥和签署交易构造用于冷存储端进行签名的交易并将签名的交易广播到区块链
In transmitting signature outputs, the majority of cold storage hardware uses data cables, Bluetooth, or even NFC. Because of the opacity of their data transmission, these methods make signature outputs extremely difficult to audit. An overlooked means of cold storage hardware communication is the QR code, a “what you see is what you get” solution. We believe the QR code is the ideal means of data transmission between cold ends and hot ends because data output by QR codes is transparent. This enables users to easily ensure each unsigned transaction that is transmitted to the cold storage device is valid, as well as ensure signature outputs from the cold end do not reveal private keys or sensitive information in any way.
在传输签名输出时蓝牙甚至NFC。 由于其数据传输的不透明性这是一种“所见即所得”的解决方案。 我们认为QR码是在冷端和热端之间进行数据传输的理想方式并确保来自冷端的签名输出不会以任何方式泄露私钥或敏感信息。
Our article onCobo Vault inputs and outputsoffers detailed instructions on how QR code signature transmissions can be “audited.”
我们有关Cobo Vault输入和输出的文章提供了有关如何“审核” QR码签名传输的详细说明。
While Cobo Vault believes that open source does not have much meaning for enhancing the security of hardware wallets, we have still released thefirmware codefor the Cobo Vault’s Secure Element. In doing so, we enable our users to see that random numbers are generated by a true random number generator and not by a pseudorandom number generator . For a detailed explanation of the importance of random numbers, refer to ourarticleon difference between true random numbers and pseudorandom numbers.
尽管Cobo Vault认为开放源代码对于增强硬件钱包的安全性没有多大意义但我们仍然发布了Cobo Vault安全元素的固件代码。 这样而不是由伪随机数生成器生成的。 有关随机数重要性的详细说明请参阅有关真正随机数和伪随机数之间差异的文章。
摆在两年前,我肯定难以想象竟然现在大部分人都已经不用钱包了?本来很有信心想采访大家,看看最被拥戴的款式到底是什么,结果很多人给我的回答都是 —— “钱包早被我扔了”。但对于没有钱包简直不能过活的我来说,没钱包,就意味着不能出门好吗!所以,我非常不容易地找到了10位还在使用钱包的女生,发现钱包对于她们来说,不仅是收纳用的,竟也有着各种和钱包之间的故事。
“世界那么大,我想去看看”很多人都想到处去看看,奈何“钱包那么小,哪也去不了”。其实云南当地的大型旅行社也没有赚我们多少钱,只是中间商太多,才出现这样的差价。加上为了保证旅游产业链条的平衡发展,当地旅行社也不去揭露罢了。现在你明白了,为什么我说“世界那么大,我想去看看,钱包那么小,哪也去不了”的背后真相。
梦见偷别人的钱包,会受到人们的尊敬。女人梦见鼓鼓囊囊的钱包,会背叛丈夫。女人梦见空钱包,会更加爱丈夫。女人梦见拿别人的钱包,丈夫会不喜欢她。少女梦见拿到恋人装满钱的钱包,不久会结为伴侣。钱包男人梦见给别人钱包,是祥瑞。梦见给仇人钱包,会降服仇人。梦见钱包丢失了,不久会买房置地。梦见强行抢别人的钱包,会官运亨通。
微信钱包的余额提现了银行卡可以免除手续费了你知道吗?大家好欢迎来到科技熊最近有好多朋友咨询我这样的一个问题比如说我微信上零钱,把它提现到银行卡如何免除手续费。因为现在我们在微信余额里提现,都会收取手续费,咨询这个问题的朋友也是比较多。实际呢,在我们微信支付选项里有个支付优惠这个功能,在我们提现的时候可以直接免除手续费,可能好多朋友还不知道今天我们详细来操作一下,在这里可以分为三步给大家讲解。不会的话,建议大家多看几遍。
其次是应用内的功能图标也统一执行了这一设计思路,其中以“钱包”图标变化最大 —— 不仅如此,连功能名称也由“钱包”更名为“支付”。1.应用、功能图标大改 首先是APP的图标发生了改变:从上图与之前的两个大版本的对比图中可以看出,新版图标相比之前更倾于扁平化,这种扁平、商务的极简设计,正是目前科技圈内较为主流的设计思路。
今天给大家带来可爱零钱包的折纸教程,虽然现在大家都在使用移动支付来付款,但是生活中一些零钱还是会用到的,小朋友们不知道该怎么存放,就可以自己动手折一个可爱的零钱包来存放硬币和零钱。大家可以选用任何自己喜欢的纸张来进行制作,接下来跟着猪小崽儿一起动手做起来吧!14.把盖子查到绑带里,这样你就得到了一个可爱的零钱包。
稻草人属于中档品牌。弗瑞达于1981年正式创立“稻草人MEXICAN”品牌。1981年,弗瑞达家族在墨西哥的墨西哥城的“ZLALO”广场附近开设第一个“稻草人MEXICO”专卖店,经营皮带、钱包、皮包、烟具、箱包、袜子以及休闲服饰。
自己动手制作一款超靓丽的拼布长钱包吧,不同颜色、质地的漂亮布头经过巧妙混搭缝纫,DIY制作出一款暖暖的钱包,太让人心动了!而且这款拼布长钱包的空间设计超大,非常实用,外观清新甜美很适合女生使用。具体这款长钱包的手工制作步骤,请参考下面的详细图解教程。以下是完成后的长钱包效果图,很漂亮实用吧!非常值得期待的手工布艺制作,喜欢拼布的女生千万别放过哦。
怎样简单的制作钱包?怎样叠漂亮的小钱包 包包应该怎么做 实用钱包简单制作 亲子手工:手包 怎样diy 一个简单方便的钱...怎么制作眼影 如何简单制作钱包 亲子手工:一分钟简单制作...加载更多~61条相关视频...
1. 云南公投网点办理的:请到各网点充值,面额必须是100的倍数。可现金或者刷卡。 2. 建设银行办理的:到各网点充值,面额必须是100的倍数,现金或者刷卡。与银行信用卡绑... 1. 云南公投网点办理的:请到各网点充值,面额必须是100的倍数。可现金或者刷卡。 2. 建设银行办理的:到各网点充值,面额必须是100的倍数,现金或者刷卡。
可以通过OPPO钱包APP存储公交卡。因为OPPO R17内置自带的NFC芯片,可以支持NFC快速支付,而OPPO钱包APP支持存储各种类型的公交卡。只需打开APP,选择“添加公交卡”,根据... 可以通过OPPO钱包APP存储公交卡。因为OPPO R17内置自带的NFC芯片,可以支持NFC快速支付,而OPPO钱包APP支持存储各种类型的公交卡。
属于中航。鲸钱包是中航信托旗下的平台,是为了中航员工的内部交易金融服务平台,只对中航的员工提供软件平台的相关服务,属于公司的私有平台。
送钱包的祝福语简短 9.祝你钱包里财运旺,福禄两旺幸福家;10.祝你钱包里财源滚滚,财运亨通,福禄寿全。1.祝你新钱包里一路发,财源滚滚进你家;2.祝你钱包里财源滚滚,红红财运进你家;3.祝你钱包里财源滚滚,财运亨通永不断;4.祝你钱包里财源滚滚,家里财源滚滚来;5.祝你钱包里钞票滚滚,家庭财源永不断;